Bad Nature - by Andrew McCumber (Paperback)

About the Book

"Offers insights into the social and cultural implications of humans' relationships with rats and the natural world. Apart from the occasional pet owner who has rats, most people regard rats as disease-carrying nocturnal pests, scurrying around dumpsters and dragging slices of pizza through New York City subways. Since rats are seemingly omnipresent in human life, why do we harbor such negative feelings about them, and why are they among the creatures most frequently targeted for systematic extermination? In Bad Nature, sociologist Andrew McCumber draws out the cultural underpinnings of rat extermination across three countries and two continents. Drawing from ethnographic, interview, and textual data from the frigid prairie of Alberta, Canada; the heart of downtown Los Angeles, California; and the iconic Galâapagos Islands of Ecuador, McCumber studies how humans have sought to suppress and exterminate rat populations in a variety of environmental, social, and political situations. He shows how, in these disparate locations, rat control is a social practice that draws and clarifies the spatial and symbolic boundaries between "good" and "bad" forms of nature. Rats are near the bottom of a symbolic hierarchy of species that places human life at the top, companion animals and majestic wildlife just below them, and the "invasive species" that call for systematic extermination at the very bottom. This hierarchy of living things that places rats at the bottom, McCumber argues, mirrors human systems of social inequalities and power dynamics. Both original and engaging, Bad Nature urges readers to consider, when charting a just and sustainable future, where will the rats be placed in the worlds we envision?"--

Book Synopsis

Offers insights into the social and cultural implications of humans' relationships with rats and the natural world.

Apart from the occasional pet owner who has rats, most people regard rats as disease-carrying nocturnal pests, scurrying around dumpsters and dragging slices of pizza through New York City subways. Since rats are seemingly omnipresent in human life, why do we harbor such negative feelings about them, and why are they among the creatures most frequently targeted for systematic extermination?

In Bad Nature, sociologist Andrew McCumber draws out the cultural underpinnings of rat extermination across three countries and two continents. Drawing from ethnographic, interview, and textual data from the frigid prairie of Alberta, Canada; the heart of downtown Los Angeles, California; and the iconic Galápagos Islands of Ecuador, McCumber studies how humans have sought to suppress and exterminate rat populations in a variety of environmental, social, and political situations. He shows how, in these disparate locations, rat control is a social practice that draws and clarifies the spatial and symbolic boundaries between "good" and "bad" forms of nature. Rats are near the bottom of a symbolic hierarchy of species that places human life at the top, companion animals and majestic wildlife just below them, and the "invasive species" that call for systematic extermination at the very bottom. This hierarchy of living things that places rats at the bottom, McCumber argues, mirrors human systems of social inequalities and power dynamics.

Both original and engaging, Bad Nature urges readers to consider, when charting a just and sustainable future, where will the rats be placed in the worlds we envision?

Review Quotes

"Bad Nature makes a compelling case for understanding rats as a problem for the spatial organization of environments, across rural, urban, and island settings, and agricultural, municipal, and conservationist contexts."

--Caroline Hovanec "Animal History"

"This book offers a useful bridge between animal studies and environmental sociology, although its allegiances are more with the latter than the former. . . . Bad Nature makes a compelling case for understanding rats as a problem for the spatial organization of environments, across rural, urban, and island settings, and agri-cultural, municipal, and conservationist contexts."

-- "Animal History" (12/4/2025 12:00:00 AM)

"In Bad Nature, McCumber's incisive and often witty account of three distinct rat problems nibbles at the edges of human-animal dynamics. The humble rat becomes a scapegoat for moral panics and social anxieties, reflecting cultural boundaries and social inequalities. The book reveals rats as potent symbols at the border between order and disorder, us and them, and we learn much from McCumber about how people seek to assert control over chaos. Who are the real pests in these cultural dramas? Spoiler: it's not always the rats."--Terence McDonnell, University of Notre Dame

"Some animals get documentaries; others get exterminators. But why? In this fresh and compelling exploration, McCumber blends rigorous data with sharp social analysis to ask a question as strange as it is important: Who's the real problem--us or the rats? This original work positions McCumber as a leading voice in the cultural study of human-animal relationships." --Justin Farrell, Yale University

About the Author

Andrew McCumber is assistant professor of sociology at Virginia Tech University. His research on cultural meaning and nature has previously been published in journals including Sociological Forum, Cultural Sociology, and Poetics, along with interdisciplinary outlets such as Environmental Humanities and Nature + Culture.