Target New Arrivals Gift Ideas for Dad Clothing, Shoes & Accessories Home & Decor Kitchen & Dining Outdoor Living & Garden Grocery Household Essentials Baby Beauty Personal Care Sports & Outdoors Health Wellness Luggage School & Office Supplies Toys Electronics Video Games Movies, Music & Books Party Supplies Gift Ideas Gift Cards Pets Ulta Beauty at Target Shop by Community Target Optical Deals Clearance New Arrivals Spring Outfits Gift Ideas for Mom Women’s Festival Outfits Top Deals Target Circle Deals Weekly Ad Shop Order Pickup Shop Same Day Delivery Registry RedCard Target Circle Find Stores

mystery plushies

Popular Filters

1,000+ results for “mystery plushies”

$11.99

Aphmau 6" Elemental Mystery Plush

(88)

$11.99

Moriah Elizabeth 6" PDQ Babies Mystery Plush

Moriah Elizabeth

(29)

$21.99

Aphmau Elemental Mystery MeeMeow Plush

(54)

Loved for: cute design

$5.79

was $7.49

New lower price

Squishmallows 5" Scented Foil Bag Blinds Stuffed Animal: Polyester Fantasy Toy, Non-Animal Design

(98)

Recommendations for you

Highly rated
$11.99
Moriah Elizabeth 6" PDQ Babies Mystery Plush
4.7 out of 5 stars with 29 ratings
Highly rated
$11.99
Aphmau 6" Elemental Mystery Plush
4.7 out of 5 stars with 88 ratings
Highly rated
$10.39
Moriah Elizabeth 6" Blob Universe Mystery Plush
4.6 out of 5 stars with 19 ratings
Highly rated
$6.49
DreamWorks Dragons How to Train Your Dragon, Mini Surprise Dragons Plush Toys, 3" Mystery Dragon Plushies (Unbox 1 of 5 Styles)
4.1 out of 5 stars with 93 ratings
Highly rated
$5.79
was $7.49 New lower price
Squishmallows 5" Scented Foil Bag Blinds Stuffed Animal: Polyester Fantasy Toy, Non-Animal Design
4.4 out of 5 stars with 98 ratings
Highly rated
$11.99
Aphmau 6" Dragons Plush
4.7 out of 5 stars with 45 ratings
Highly rated
$5.99
Aphmau Mystery MeeMeows Figures in PDQ Elemental series 7
4.7 out of 5 stars with 37 ratings
$5.99
Moriah Elizabeth Mystery figures
4.8 out of 5 stars with 19 ratings

$10.39

Moriah Elizabeth 6" Blob Universe Mystery Plush

Moriah Elizabeth

(19)

$39.99

Squishmallows Mystery Box 5-Inch Plush 5 Pack - Official Jazwares Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Mini Stuffed Animal - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys

(17)

$9.99

Snackles Disney 5" Capsule Stuffed Animal: Characters Include Bear, Elephant, Mouse, Monster, Alien

(77)

Loved for: adorable designs

$21.99

Warrior Cats Large Mystery Plush

(20)

Loved for: cute design

Sponsored

$11.99

Warrior Cats Mini Mystery Plush

(37)

$11.99

Aphmau 6" Dragons Plush

(45)

$6.49

DreamWorks Dragons How to Train Your Dragon, Mini Surprise Dragons Plush Toys, 3" Mystery Dragon Plushies (Unbox 1 of 5 Styles)

How to Train Your Dragon

(93)

$4.99

Littlest Pet Shop Surprise Reveal Collectible Plush Pets

Littlest Pet Shop

(55)

Related deals

Highly rated
$24.99
reg $39.99 Sale
The Simpsons Good and Evil 16" Talking Krusty Pull String Doll Plush
4.2 out of 5 stars with 131 ratings
$15.99
reg $29.99 Sale
Minecraft Movie Bee Plush Toy, Soft Block-Style Character, Collectible Stuffed Animal
$10.99 - $33.99
reg $12.99 - $35.99 Sale
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles MiraBall, 3-in-1 Surprise, Blind Box Toys for Kids - Collectable Characters - Metal Ball, Plush, Stickers, White Ribbon
5 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
$12.99
reg $17.99 Sale
Miraball Surprises Paw Patrol - Blind Capsule Toy with Expandable Memory Foam Plush & Stickers - Fun Mystery Plush Ball for Kids Collecting
5 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
$35.99
reg $39.99 Sale
Bebefinn Plush Toy - 12" Stuffed Doll
5 out of 5 stars with 13 ratings
See price in cart
Joyfy 36Pcs Kids Mini Plush Animal Toy Set Easter Christmas Bulk Stuffed Keychain Party Favors Animals Decoration Toys Carnival Prizes Birthday Gift
5 out of 5 stars with 3 ratings
$12.99
reg $17.99 Sale
Miraball Surprises SpongeBob - Blind Capsule Toy with Expandable Memory Foam Plush & Stickers - Fun Mystery Plush Ball for Kids Collecting
$16.99
reg $21.99 Sale
Great Eastern - Great Eastern - My Hero Academia - 8" Plush - Tsuyu Asui Seifuku (MHA)
$13.99
reg $19.99 Sale
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem Raphael 8 Inch Plush Toy
1 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
$19.99
reg $33.32 Sale
Joyfy 4 Pcs Emotional Support Plushies, Easter Fast Food Plush Stuffed Toys Set, Cute Burger Fries & Milkshake Plush Pillow Fun Comfort Food Gift Box
$9.99
reg $12.99 Sale
Trolls Band Together Hairmony Mixers Branch Plush Toy with Sound
$23.99
reg $27.99 Sale
Miraball Bibi Emoji, Surprise Egg Capsules with Memory Foam Expandable Plush Toys – 3.7" (9.5cm) Soft Collectibles with Surprises Each – (Pack of 3)
$10.99 - $31.45
reg $12.99 - $35.99 Sale
Peppa Pig MiraBall, 3-in-1 Surprise, Blind Box Toys for Kids - Collectable Characters from TV Shows - Metal Ball, Plush, Stickers, White Ribbon
5 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
$11.99
reg $14.99 Sale
Funko Plush Keychain Mystery Mini: Harry Potter (One Random Mystery Mini Figure Per Purchase)
$26.99
reg $29.99 Sale
Solo Leveling S2 - Tank (Shadow) Sitting Plush 7"H
$16.99
reg $21.99 Sale
Great Eastern - Great Eastern - My Hero Academia S2 - 8" Plush - Himiko Toga Battle Form (MHA)
$9.99
reg $12.99 Sale
Miraball Bibi Sport - Surprise Egg Capsule with Memory Foam Expandable Plush Toy – 3.7" (9.5cm) Soft Collectible with Hidden Surprises – Fun Gift
$10.99 - $33.99
reg $12.99 - $35.99 Sale
Transformers MiraBall, 3-in-1 Surprise, Blind Box Toys for Kids - Collectable Characters from TV Shows - Metal Ball, Plush, Stickers, White Ribbon
5 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
$16.99
reg $21.99 Sale
Great Eastern - Great Eastern - My Hero Academia S2 - 7" Sitting Plush - Ochako Uraraka Seifuku (MHA)
$23.99
reg $29.99 Sale
Super7 - Super7 - Toho - Super Duper Plush Wv2 - Mothra '64
$26.99
reg $29.99 Sale
Solo Leveling S2 - Igris Plush 8"H
5 out of 5 stars with 3 ratings
$10.99
reg $12.99 Sale
Emoji MiraBall, 3-in-1 Surprise, 1 Pack, Blind Box Toys for Kids - Collectable Pieces - Metal Ball, Plush, Stickers, White Ribbon
$12.99
reg $16.99 Sale
Funko Five Nights at Freddys Frostbite Balloon Boy Plush
5 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
$16.99
reg $21.99 Sale
Great Eastern - Great Eastern - My Hero Academia S2 - 8" Plush - Hitoshi Shinso (MHA)

$29.99

Kimmon Dream Maker Blind Box – Sour Series Plush Collectible Mystery Doll with Keychain, 6-7” Ultra-Soft Plush Characters for Collecting

(16)

$29.99

Kimmon Dream Maker Blind Box – Sweet Series Plush Collectible Mystery Doll with Keychain, 6-7” Ultra-Soft Plush Characters for Collecting

(13)

$8.99

Moriah Elizabeth Valentine Plush

Moriah Elizabeth

(13)

$9.99

Aphmau Mystery Plush - Royals

(39)

Sponsored

$3.99

Squishmallows 2.5" MicroMallows Blinds Stuffed Animal: Plush Kids Toy, Polyester, Animal Design Varies

(117)

Loved for: softness

$11.99

Aphmau Valentine Plush

(25)

$9.99

ZURU 5 Surprise Anime Pop Plush: Mythical Creature Stuffed Toy, Polyester Material

(67)

$6.99

Disney Frozen Mini Collectible Plush (Series 5) Mystery 5-inch Collectible Plushie

(64)

Loved for: adorable designs

$22.99

LankyBox Giant Mystery 11" Plush

(37)

$9.99

was $11.99

New lower price

PrestonPlayz Mini Mystery Plush Series 1

(20)

$9.99

Happy Haul Duckalooz Snack Quack Plush Duck Clip-On Blind Box 5” Collectible Stuffed Toy with Removable Costume Short-Run Drop Ages 8+

(15)

$11.99

GUND Pusheen Surprise Cafe

(17)

Sponsored

Get top deals, latest trends, and more.