Too Faced Killer Liner 36 Hour Waterproof Gel Eyeliner - 0.04oz - Ulta Beauty

As much as I want to give this product five stars, I cannot. I bought this recently and I like to wear eyeliner regularly. I was under the assumption since it was a two-faced product they would provide you with a sharpener or give you more product than what is there. I tried to sharpen it, however it broke. As much as I pay for this, I feel I should be getting more product than what it really has. As well as the eyeliner would get all over the pencil top whenever I put the lid back on so the actual eyeliner pencil always looked messy because of how easy the eyeliner moved around, which I feel made the product go faster than it should have. The pros for this though is the black is great. It is very buildable, and it is definitely waterproof and stays all day. I would definitely buy this again IF TWO-FACED makes a sharpener with it or a twist to be able to get more product. I know that they can do this because their eyeshadow pencil comes with a sharpener at the bottom of it so I'm very confused as to why they don't have it for this eyeliner pencil.

When I tight line, it transfers on to my eye ball and smears easily

It is good for smudging as an eyeshadow for a smoky eye. Most definitely cannot use it as an eyeliner.

I tried several eyelines including waterproof ones for my hooded eyes. I'm in my late 50s. They all ran or smudged. This liner stays put, doesn't run, doesn't smudge into my lids. I can deal with having to sharpen it.

Formula might be good but stick only lasted one for one use.

I tear up a lot from allergies but i dont have any issues with this liner running at all. I have some basic sharpeners on hand and it sharpens to a point. So i didnt know that was an issue for some people till i read reviews . It's a very ideal formula for me and i love the color range for my green eyes. I got a few colors but this killer chocolate is my everyday go to

The pencil doesn't twist- I cant believe that material can be sharpened. For the $$ not worth it.

This is the weirdest applicator ive encountered. Skip this product - there are much better products available.

only used a few times. Goes on nicely. May be causing my eyes to tear. That's the only new eye product I have used and had a little burning. Will try again.

The tip is not stable and "smooshed" after using. Never had an experience like this before! My suggestion—too costly for this imperfections-Do not purchase.

This is a nice product in and of itself. The liner does not have a twist end for the user to make the tip longer as desired. This is an expensive liner, that doesn't really seem to meet my needs. I was hopeful after first use and then disappointed.

CAN NOT Sharpen, keeps breaking off. Color is good though.

I am very disappointed with this eyeliner. Definitely not waterproof nor smudge proof. Leaves me with raccoon eyes.

Used one time and there was no more liner, tip broke off and no liner pencil to sharpen

I bought it because it was on sale and it said all the things that I wanted an eyeliner to do I didn't even have it on for two hours and already it melted and I had raccoon Eyes

It really does stay on til I take it off and doesn't smear or give me raccoon eyes! You gotta love that!!!

This is not waterproof. Wish I had read the reviews before buying. At least it was on sale.

Bottom line whoever is having issues with this just needs to buy the ESSENCE SHARPENER! Its cheap it sharpens beautifully even with the plastic 0 issues and even tho its already mentioned the formulation is great! Even for the upper lid!

I bought 9 eyeliner @ hsn when they were on sale.3 for me 3 for my daughter and 3 for my bestie.@ first they were amazing now they don't even work.i am so upset cause same issue with the sharpening.do I have to get a lighter and burn the end .like we used too back in the 80's

I have very sparse eyelashes, so I like a long-wear eyeliner that I can smudge. This absolutely delivered, but when it came time to sharpen it....well, you just couldn't. The plastic is too hard to sharpen, and you will never have a sharp point again. So disappointing.