Stila DELUXE Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner- Intense Black - 0.008 fl oz - Ulta Beauty

To dry!

What happened to the quality of this eyeliner? It used to take much longer for it to dry up. Now it dries up in a week. I'm moving on to other brands.

This was my go to eyeliner for wings for YEARS! I loved it. Now? It creases, it doesn't stay on, it rubs away just by blinking, and the formula dries SO quickly now. Furthermore, the felt tip of the eyliner pen used to be amazing abd easyvto use. Now? Its flimsy, hard to get the perfect cat eye, and product doesn't come out easily at all. I used to love this product. Now, I cant stand it. Dont buy it. Its a waste of monet at this point.

Bought this after looking for hard to find gray eyeliner. I will not purchase this again, it's almost like there is the tiniest amount of product in it. If you get the least amount of makeup where you've applied this liner, it doesn't go on at all. I will be surprised if this lasts even a month.

It dried within a week or two, and i dont even use eyeliner every day. I prefer the kat von d liquid eyeliner.

I bought this to replace my liquid liner that was drying up, and this new product is somehow dryer than the old product! So frustrating to use.

I use it for eyebrows. It works well. No smear.

Love this and stays in place, lasts a long time. I have been using it for years

After 4-5 uses both tip and eyeliner dried. I keep it facing down and keep shaking it while applying. For 1st eye it works but by the time I reach 2nd eye it's very hard to get wing done. It gets applied like paint layer so gets creased & not smooth

I do heavy black winged eyeliner every day. I have been a faithful customer to NYX for their black eyeliner but have been finding issues with their applicator leaking product. I wanted to treat myself to a new and more expensive eyeliner. THIS was not it. When i opened it, it was dry and i had to manually wet it in order to get product out of it. Extremely disappointed.

I got this product for free and it is absolutely amazing. Dried quickly and stay all day. Thank you so much!!!

Even after storing upside down, this is super dried out and basically unusable. Super disappointing.

The color is utterly perfect, a deep midnight blue. The shape of yhe tip is great. After maybe ten uses it wa dried up. It would pull the pigment off the lid, not seposit more. I tried storing it upside down, delressing the tip…really fristrating and disappointing purchase

I received a birthday sample of this product (black color) from Ulta, and found it to be really good. It's quick and easy to use. The following month, I bought a full size brown, but the felt tip was rather skippy and product was basically dryish. So I exchanged it for another full size (black this time) and so far, so good.

Straight out of the box I was having issues with it being dry by time I got to the wing on my 2nd eye. After wearing for 1 hour, doing nothing but working at my desk in the A/C, it had started to flake and fade. 😞

I only used this liner a few times before it was dried up. The felt tip was also hard to push to get liner to come out.

This eyeliner was thankfully my FOREVER eyeliner for the last decade and some; didn't smudge after a long messy day at work (in healthcare), and with monolids these were stellar. Easy to remove at end of day without stubborn smudging. However, my most recent purchase of this eyeliner in the black (and I tried them all to make sure it wasn't a one-off mistake) was not the same formula at all. Smudging within the morning, difficult to remove at night (very stubborn smudgy..) It also does not look the same when applied. It doesn't dry matte like it used to; it has a foil-y sheen like Fenty's liquid liner, and my same setting shadow I've used for the last 5 years doesn't sink as well into the liner either. I hope they bring back the original formula please!!! In the meantime I unfortunately will have to find another liquid black liner :(

Stay All Day was my gold standard for liquid eyeliner. I didn't want to use anything else. It made bold, crisp lines effortlessly that lasted all day and then came off easily and gently at night with micellar water. Then my pen ran out and I ordered a replacement a few months ago from the Stila site, and it just was not the same. It didn't adhere to my skin as well and it went on kinda transparent and needed numerous layers to look dark and solid. Then that pen ran out and I ordered another one last week, and it seems different yet again. I still need to go over it numerous times to get a dark black line, but now suddenly micellar water does practically nothing to remove it and I end up needing to use harsher products on my eyes to get it off before bed. I still use Stay All Day often, but I'm starting to experiment with other brands again because I've become a bit disappointed with my favorite eyeliner. I want my old Stay All Day back again 😭 I'm not sure if I'm just getting weird batches (from the official site), or if they've reformulated it into something that doesn't work as well for me. It's still a great eyeliner once I'm done struggling to put it on--I get compliments on it regularly still and it stays put all day as advertised, but it went from easy to frustrating in both application and removal.

Wanted to love this. Although it goes on easily, it doesnt stay put. my eyelids were consistently smudged, hust in the course of the day (and i have contacts, so dont rub my eyes.) Having to trade in for an eyeliner that actually stays in place.

I was trying to find a product to replace a liquid eye liner that I loved, but this is not it. As soon as you put it on, it's so runny it goes everywhere and is hard to clean off.